Nest 3rd Generation vs. Nest E: Which smart thermostat is best for you?

Android Central

Android Central
Android Central
At Mobile Nations, we love smart home tech, and I've been a Nest user since the first generation in 2012. We know what makes them tick and why that matters.

Nest 3rd Generation


Full-color, big display

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Pros

  • 3.25-inch full color display
  • Far-Field Activity sensor
  • Supports 95 percent of all heating and cooling systems
  • Multiple color options
Cons

  • Price
  • No Homekit support

The latest Nest Learning Thermostat works with almost every type of HVAC system, has a display that's readable from across the room, and supports FarSight to help save money by knowing when you're home. It even comes in seven different colors! It's not cheap, though.

Nest E


Save energy and money

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Pros

  • Price
  • Supports 85 percent of all systems
Cons

  • No Far-Field Sensor
  • No Homekit support

The Nest E is the most inexpensive model from the company and does almost everything the pricier models can. It does lack FarSight and the display is pretty basic, though.


Nest makes easy-to-install and easy-to-use smart thermostats, and both the 3rd-generation model and the Nest E are current products that work great. They both work for almost every type of HVAC system and can even control a water boiler for steam heat or hot water. The differences are more than just cosmetic, though.

Get smart and save money


The major difference you need to know is that the Nest E doesn't support Nest's FarSight tech. It's the feature that can sense you walking in the door, will wake up the thermostat, and can override any energy-saving settings you might have programmed for the times you're not home. The Nest E does have a proximity and occupancy sensor, but it's not quite the same and doesn't work nearly as well.

Nest 3rd Gen Nest E
Dimensions Diameter 3.25 inches
Depth 1.21 inches Diameter 3.19 inches
Depth 1.14 inches
Display 3.25 inch
480 x 480 px 1.76 inch
320 x 320 px
Connectivity 802.11 b/g/n
802.15.4
Bluetooth LE 802.11 b/g/n
802.15.4
Bluetooth LE
App-control Nest App
Amazon Alexa
Google Assistant Nest App
Amazon Alexa
Google Assistant
Sensors Temperature
Humidity
Near-Field Activity
Far-Field Activity
Ambient Light Temperature
Humidity
Proximity/Occupancy
Ambient Light
Features Auto-Schedule
Airwave
Nest Leaf
Auto-Away
Energy History
Time to Temperature
System Match
Early On
Heat Pump Balance
FarSight
Water / Boiler control Auto-Schedule
Airwave
Nest Leaf
Auto-Away
Energy History
Time to Temperature
System Match
Early On
Heat Pump Balance
Water / Boiler control
Colors Stainless steel
white
black
copper
polished steel
brass
mirror black White
Trim Ring Polished metal Polycarbonate

If you want a simple to install and use smart thermostat that will save you money on your heating and cooling bills, Nest has you covered. Both models are compatible with most HVAC systems and a combination of the Nest App and your favorite Smart Home Assistant will keep you comfortable while saving potentially hundreds every year. A recent audit from my power company showed a $181 savings in 2017 for people who used smart environmental controls, and that's a good bit of change.

There are two differences that matter between the Nest 3rd Gen and the Nest E: The look of the unit itself and support for Nest's FarSight. The first is readily obvious; the Nest E comes in a white polycarbonite shell with a smaller display that gives less information at a glance than the more expensive Nest 3rd Gen. Though it's worth mentioning that a field-of-view effect makes the Nest E's display look like part of the unit and not a screen and is a nice touch.


Nest's FarSight is a neat trick, but I wouldn't let it be the deciding factor.

FarSight is a Nest feature that's designed to let you know what's going on from across the room. Most people love it for one reason — when they come home they can see that the Nest knows they are home, has adjusted the target temperature (if needed) because of it, and it's an indicator that says everything is working as expected. The Nest E lacks FarSight and doesn't have the sensor required.

This isn't a dealbreaker, though. The Nest E does have proximity and occupancy sensors that tell it someone is at home so it too can make adjustments, you just don't know it from across the room — you'll have to walk over and check or use the app on your phone.

FarSight is a nifty feature. In my home, we actually use it to show the current time because we're smartphone junkies who can see any relevant info with the tap of a home screen icon. It's just not necessarily worth the added cost of the 3rd Generation. The better display and broader selection of colors might be, though, as your home is an investment and matching any decor is often worth some added costs.

One final thing to know about both models is the lack of support for Apple Homekit. If you're using Homekit as your smart home platform of choice, you'll need to go with an
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
, which is also an excellent choice.

As a long-time Nest user, I say as long as you're OK with white, save the money and go with the Nest E. Make sure it works with your system first though!

Nest 3rd Gen


Full-color, big display

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


The Nest flagship

The latest Nest Learning Thermostat works with almost every type of HVAC system, has a display that's readable from across the room, and supports FarSight to help save money by knowing when you're home. It might be too expensive for some, however.

Nest E


Save energy and money

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Nest's best value

The Nest E is the most inexpensive model from the company and does almost everything the pricier models can. It does lack FarSight and the display is pretty basic, though.

9dUr16_QCdA


Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top