Which version of the Galaxy S8 is the one to buy?
Samsung has continued the trend of releasing an "Active" version of its latest mass-market flagship a handful of months later, and the Galaxy S8 Active is the least compromised Active model yet. It thankfully shares a vast majority of the components, features and experience with a standard Galaxy S8 — and that's a definite selling point compared to the rest of the rugged phone market.
So how does the Galaxy S8 Active compare to its standard counterpart? We're here to lay out all of the differences, big and small.
What's the same
As we went into detail on in our complete Galaxy S8 Active review, one of the best features of the phone is that it behaves and performs like the standard Galaxy S8 in just about every way. It's built on the exact same platform of specs, with the same exact software features and hardware components. You won't notice a difference in daily use no matter which one you pick up, and that's wonderful.
In daily use, these phones are identical.
The Galaxy S8 has its fans and its skeptics, but the general feeling on the phone is that it's fast and super-capable in terms of the raw number of software features it offers. Being an AT&T-exclusive phone (for now) you'll have to deal with some extra bloatware and small superfluous software changes, but you get that on an AT&T-branded Galaxy S8 as well. The camera continues to perform with the best in the industry, with a great consistency you don't always get even in high-end phones.
More: Samsung Galaxy S8 and S8+ specs
A Snapdragon 835 processor is still the top of the line, and 4GB of RAM is more than enough. 64GB of storage remains on the Active, and you keep an SD card slot as well. Despite the rugged exterior you don't have to deal with any additional flaps or port coverings, either — you even keep the 3.5 mm headphone jack. Its thick back case still gives you wireless charging as well. Even though it's more actively styled the GS8 Active has the same IP68 water and dust resistance, but that's still the standard we can realistically expect on mass-market phones.
You can probably guess that the biggest difference here is the external hardware design. The GS8 Active is indeed very rugged, and not in the way a standard GS8 can be tough with the addition of a big case — there's an extra bit of security about knowing that the exterior rubber and tough plastic is part of the phone. There are big bumpers on the corners, notable extra thickness throughout, a housing surrounding the camera and a tough plastic textured back that's easier to hold onto and so much more resilient than glass.
The GS8 Active looks like it can take a drop without worry — and it actually can.
That, of course, means that the Galaxy S8 Active is also much larger and all-around tougher to use in one hand than the extremely svelte standard model. A Galaxy S8 measures up at 148.9 x 68.1 x 8 mm and 155 g. The Active? 151.89 x 74.93 x 9.91 mm, 208.09 g. Those are big change, particularly in width, thickness and of course weight. The Active is considerably tougher to wrap your hand around, and even though the casing makes you more confident in its robustness it's also a bit tougher to maneuver being 34% heavier than the GS8.
Completing the rugged streak of the GS8 Active is its display. It's the same great Super AMOLED panel as before, but now it's completely flat with flat glass to match. That definitely improves the ergonomics of the phone, eliminating accidental palm touches, but all of that usability is washed away by the extra thickness and width. The display is shatter-resistant, which is a claim not made on the standard GS8 and that's because the Active has a special plastic coating over its standard Gorilla Glass 5. The coating makes sure the screen won't shatter even when dropped from five feet, but the downside is the plastic is dramatically more susceptible to small everyday scratches (yes, like the Moto Z2 Force). Considering the number of people we see walking around with shattered screens it seems like they'd take that trade-off, but not everyone will prefer it.
Now, a pure and simple benefit of the Galaxy S8 Active: a larger battery. And not just a little larger, a whole 1000mAh larger — totaling 4000mAh, and making sure you really don't have to worry about battery life on this thing. Whereas the Galaxy S8 had to strike a balance in terms of size, weight and battery life, only making it a day with normal use, the Active can definitely take on a heavy day without complaining and leave you with some battery left over at the end of the day. It's one of the main reasons people are even considering the GS8 Active, and it is definitely a serious improvement.
Which should you buy?
Knowing nothing about a person's specific usage needs, if someone asks me which version to buy I'll immediately say, "get the regular Galaxy S8." Despite the massive improvement in battery life on the Active, the standard Galaxy S8 offers a much more well-rounded approach that is applicable to the widest number of people. It's beautiful, compact, easy to hold and truly feels like a high-end phone worthy of the price tag. It's also much less expensive, in the range of $150-200 less at this point — that's some serious cash.
But if you need to have a "rugged" phone and know for a fact that your Galaxy S8 will end up spending 100% of its life bolted into a seriously heavy-duty case, there's reason to consider buying the Galaxy S8 Active from the start. Assuming that the price difference isn't a big issue for you, the GS8 Active gives you the full daily experience of a Galaxy S8 without the worry of cracking glass on both sides of the phone. You'll have to deal with substantial added weight and some casual scratches on the screen protector, but in return you get massive battery life — that may be a calculation that works out for some people.
Samsung Galaxy S8 and S8+
- Galaxy S8 and S8+ review!
- Galaxy S8 and S8+ specs
- Everything you need to know about the Galaxy S8’s cameras
- Get to know Samsung Bixby
- Join our Galaxy S8 forums
Verizon AT&T T-Mobile Sprint Unlocked